legalreport TSUL Legal Report TSUL Legal Report 2181-1024 Toshkent davlat yuridik universiteti 10.51788/tsul.lr.3.2./qhlb1780 REL-A-013960 THE CONCEPT OF PROVIDING RULE-MAKING PROCESS WITH INFORMATION Sodikov Akmal 01 01 2022 2022 3 2 17 25 https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0

This article analyzes the concept, essence and charactristics of providing rule-making process with information. Along with encyclopedic materials of the Republic of Uzbekistan, the approaches and opinions of scientists have been discussed. As part of the study, the normative legal acts of the Repubic of Uzbekistan have been analyzed in detail. Author‘s definitions for the relevant notions have been developed which means that the writer achieved the purpose of this scientific research. In fact, in addition to legal research, the author developed scientifically proved definitions of several legal terms such as “information”, “information used in the rule-making process” and “providing rule-making process with information”. The issue of developing requirements for information in national legislation will be discussed by studying the scientific views on the information applied in rule-making process and the concept of providing rule-making process with information. It also examines the relevance of all types of information, regardless of the form, type, and stage of rule-making process and the importance of normative legal acts in determining viability, sustainability, and regulatory impact. It is recognized that information supply in the rule-making process and the mechanism of regulation of certain social relations affects the rational and effective perception of the normative legal acts by the general public.

 information rule-making providing rule-making process with information information used in rule-making process information supply information quality Access Info Strategy 2018-2021 of Access Info Europe. – Madrid, 2018. – P. 7-8. // https://www.access-info.org/wp-content/uploads/AIE-Strategy-2018-2021-FINAL.pdf – Official webpage of Access Info in Europe. Address of the President of the Republic of Uzbekistan Shavkat Mirziyoyev to the Oliy Majlis (28.12.2018) // https://president.uz/uz/lists/view/2228 Нажимов М.К. Норма ижодкорлиги жараёнини такомиллаштириш – давлат-ҳуқуқий ислоҳотларнинг муҳим йўналиши // Юридик фанлар ахборотномаси. – Т.: ТДЮУ, 2019. – No2. – Б. 85-88. [Najimov M.K. Improving the rule-making process – an important area of state and legal reform // Bulletin of Legal Sciences. – T .: TSUL, 2019. No2. – P. 85-88.] Парламент фаолиятини илмий ва ахборот-таҳлилий жиҳатдан таъминлашнинг долзарб масалалари. Халқаро конференция материаллари // Масъул муҳаррир: Ф.Х.Отахонов. – Т.: ҚМПТИ, 2021. – 301 б. [ See: Current issues of scientific and information-analytical support of parliamentary activity. Materials of the International Conference // Editor-in-Chief: F.Kh. Otakhanov. – T.: QMPTI, 2021. – 301 p.] Qarang: Рустамов П.А. Научно-информационное обеспечение законодательной деятельности в Республике Узбекистан. Диссертация к.ю.н.: 12.00.01. – Т.: ТГЮИ, 2001. – 149 с. [See: Rustamov P.A. Scientific and information support of legislative activity in the Republic of Uzbekistan. PhD thesis: 12.00.01. – T .: TSIL, 2001. – 149 p.] Хўжаназаров А.А. Адлия органларининг норма ижодкорлиги фаолиятини такомиллаштириш. 12.00.02 – ю.ф.ф.д. (PhD) илмий даражасини олиш учун ёзилган диссертацияси. – Т.: ТДЮУ, 2021. – 143 б. [Khujanazarov A.A. Improving the rule-making activities of the justice bodies. 12.00.02 – Dissertation for PhD degree. – T .: Tsul, 2021. – 143 p.] Султанова С.А. Теоретико-правовые вопросы применения модели «Умное регулирование» в нормотворчестве. 12.00.01 – диссертация на соискание ученой степени д.ф.п. (PhD). – Т.: ТГЮУ, 2021. – 184 с. [Sultanova S.A. Theoretical and legal issues of applying the “Smart Regulation” model in rule-making. 12.00.01 – Dissertation for PhD degree. – T .: TSUL, 2021. – 184 p.] Carey M.P. The federal rulemaking process: an overview // USA Congressional Research Service 7-5700, www.crs.gov, RL32240. CRS Report for Congress Prepared for Members and Committees of Congress. – Washington: CRS, (June 17, 2013). – 34 p. Dooling B.C.E. Legal issues in e-rulemaking // Administrative Law Review. – Washington: George Mason University, 2011. Vol. 63. – No. 4. – P. 893-932. Garvey T. A brief overview of rulemaking and judicial review // USA Congressional Research Service 7-5700, www.crs.gov, R41546. CRS Report for Congress Prepared for Members and Committees of Congress. – Washington, March 27, 2017. – 17 p. See: Lubbers J.S. А survey of federal agency rulemakers’ attitudes about e-rulemaking // Administrative Law Review. – Washington: American University Washington College of Law, 2010. Vol. 62. – No. 2. – Р. 451-486. Ярмонова Е.Н. Отличие нормотворчества от правотворчества как одна из основных проблем юриспруденции // Научно-методический электронный журнал «Концепт», 2016. – NoS16. – С. 1-7. [Yarmonova E.N. The difference between rulemaking and lawmaking as one of the main problems of jurisprudence // Scientific and methodological electronic journal “Concept”, 2016. – No. S16. – P. 1-7.] Гирько С.И. Нормотворчество как специализация сотрудников правовых подразделений // НПЖ «Диалог», 2018. – No2 (11). – С. 40-46. [Girko S.I. Rule-makingas a specialization of employees of legal departments // NPZH “Dialogue”, 2018. – No. 2 (11). – P. 40-46.] Скачкова Г.С. Профессия «норморайтер» и трудовое право // Норморайтер как профессия: материалы дискуссии. – Москва: РГ-Пресс, 2019. – 352 c. [Skachkova G.S. Profession “rulewriter” and labor law // Rulewriter as a profession: discussion materials. – Moscow: RG-Press, 2019. – 352 p.] Арзамасов Ю.Г. Нормография: теория и технология нормотворчества // – М.: Юрайт, 2017. – 460 c. [Arzamasov Yu.G. Normography: theory and technology of rulemaking // – M .: Yurayt, 2017. – 460 p.] Тонков Е.Е., Павлова К.Е. Нормотворческая деятельность органов внутренних дел: понятие и сущность // Nomothetika: Философия. Социология. Право, 2016. – No3 (224). – С. 153-159. [Tonkov E.E., Pavlova K.E. Rule-making activity of internal affairs bodies: concept and essence // Nomothetika: Philosophy. Sociology. Law, 2016. – No. 3 (224). – S. 153-159.] Нажимов М.К. Норма ижодкорлиги. – Т.: ТДЮУ, 2018. – 181 б. [Najimov M.K. Rule-making. – T .: TSUL, 2018. – 181 p.] Рузиназаров Ш., Иноятова С. Научное стратегическое прогнозирование законотворчества в частноправовой сфере: современные реалии и ориентиры // Обзор законодательства Узбекистана научно аналитический журнал. – Т.: ТГЮУ, 2017. – No3. – С. 5-8. [Ruzinazarov Sh., Inoyatova S. Scientific strategic forecasting of lawmaking in the private law sphere: modern realities and guidelines // Review of the legislation of Uzbekistan scientifically analytical journal. – T .: TSUL, 2017. – No. 3. – P. 5-8.] Ўзбекистон Миллий энциклопедияси А ҳарфи қисми. – Т.: “Ўзбекистон миллий энциклопедияси” Давлат илмий нашриёти, 2013. – Б. 812. [Part of the letter A of the National Encyclopedia of Uzbekistan. – T .: “National Encyclopedia of Uzbekistan” State Scientific Publishing House, 2013. – P. 812.] Ўзбек тилининг изоҳли луғати: 8000 га яқин сўз ва сўз бирикмаси. Жилд I. А–Д // Масъул муҳаррир Мадвалиев А. – Т.: “Ўзбекистон миллий энциклопедияси” Давлат илмий нашриёти, 2020. – Б. 119. [Annotated dictionary of the Uzbek language: about 8000 words and phrases. Volume I. A – D // Responsible editor Madvaliev A. – T .: “National Encyclopedia of Uzbekistan” State Scientific Publishing House, 2020. – P. 119.] Ўзбекистон юридик энциклопедияси // Нашр учун масъул Муҳитдинов Р.А. ва бошқ.; масъул муҳаррир Тойчиев Н. – Т.: Адолат, 2010. – Б. 35. [Legal Encyclopedia of Uzbekistan // Responsible for publication Muhitdinov R.A. et al .; responsible editor Toychiev N. – T .: Adolat, 2010. – P. 35.] National Database of Legislation, 20.04.2021, No. 03/21/682/0354. National Database of Legislation, 10.08.2020, No. 03/20/631/1153. National Database of Legislation, 19.04.2018, No. 03/18/476/1087. National Database of Legislation, 30.03.2021, No. 03/21/679/0256. 10.1055/s-0041-1731218 National Database of Legislation, 11.09.2019, No. 03/19/566/3734. National Database of Legislation, 26.01.2022, No. 03/22/747/0064. 10.56804/avishkara.2022.1307 See: Ахмедшаева М.А., Кудрявцев И.В. Қонун ижодкорлик жараёнини прогнозлаштиришнинг айрим назарий-ҳуқуқий ва ташкилий масалалари. – Т.: ProAcademy, 2018. – No1. – Б. 19-24. [Akhmedshaeva M.A., Kudryavtsev I.V. Some theoretical, legal and organizational issues of forecasting the law-making process. – T .: ProAcademy, 2018. – No1. – P. 19-24.] See: Хайитов Х.С. Қонун ижодкорлиги экспертлик таъминоти: миллий ва хорижий тажриба // Юридик фанлар ахборотномаси. – Т.: ТДЮУ, 2018. – No2. – Б. 14-19. [Khayitov X.S. Expert support of lawmaking: national and foreign experience // Bulletin of Legal Sciences. – T .: TSUL, 2018. – No2. – P. 14-19.] Садиков С.А. Ўзбекистон Республикасида “электрон ҳукумат” тизими ҳуқуқий асосларининг шаклланиши ва ривожланиши // 12.00.01 – ю.ф.ф.д. (PhD) диссертацияси автореферати. – Т.: ТДЮУ, 2020. – 57 б. [Sadikov S.A. Formation and development of the legal framework of the “e-government” system in the Republic of Uzbekistan // 12.00.01 – PhD dissertation abstract. – T .: TSUL, 2020. – 57 p.] Аманов А.А. Ахборот хизмати кўрсатишни фуқаролик-ҳуқуқий тартибга солишни такомиллаштириш // 12.00.03 – ю.ф.ф.д. (PhD) илмий даражасини олиш учун ёзилган диссертацияси. – Т.: ИИВ Академияси, 2018. – Б. 22. [Amanov A.A. Improving the civil law regulation of information services // 12.00.03 - PhD dissertation for a degree. – T .: MIA Academy, 2018. – P. 22.] Худойбердиев А.Қ. Ҳуқуқ ижодкорлиги фаолиятини социологик ва эксперт-таҳлилий таъминлашни такомиллаштириш // 12.00.01. – ю.ф.д. (DSc) илмий даражасини олиш учун диссертация. – Т.: ИИВ Академияси, 2020. – 258 б. [Khudoyberdiev A.K. Improving the sociological and expert-analytical support of lawmaking // 12.00.01. –Dissertation for DSc academic degree. – T .: MIA Academy, 2020. – 258 p.] Маматов Х.Т. Ўзбекистон Республикасида фуқароларнинг ахборотга бўлган ҳуқуқларини амалга оширишнинг конституциявий-ҳуқуқий асослари // 12.00.02. ю.ф.н. илмий даражасини олиш учун ёзилган диссертация автореферати. – Т.: ТДЮИ, 2009. – 164 б. [Mamatov Kh.T. Constitutional and legal bases of realization of citizens’ right to information in the Republic of Uzbekistan // 12.00.02. Abstract of the dissertation for PhD degree. – T .: TSIL, 2009. – 164 p.] Маматов Х.Т. Ўзбекистон Республикасида фуқароларнинг ахборотга бўлган ҳуқуқларини амалга оширишнинг конституциявий ҳуқуқий асослари // 12.00.02 – ю.ф.н. илмий даражасини олиш учун ёзилган диссертацияси. – Т.: СамДУ, 2009. – Б. 20-21. [Mamatov Kh.T. Constitutional and legal bases of realization of citizens’ right to information in the Republic of Uzbekistan // 12.00.02. Abstract of the dissertation for PhD degree. – T .: TSIL, 2009. – P. 20-21.] Рустамов П.А. Научно-информационное обеспечение законодательной деятельности в Республике Узбекистан // Диссертация к.ю.н.: 12.00.01. – Т.: ТГЮИ, 2001. – 149 с. [Rustamov P.A. Scientific and information support of legislative activity in the Republic of Uzbekistan // Dissertation PhD in Law: 12.00.01. – T .: TSIL, 2001. – 149 p.] See: Borghetto E., Giuliani M. The pace of the legislative process: A diachronic analysis of the Italian legislature (1996–2006) // Societá Italiana di Scienza politica. 2008. – P. 4-6. See: Klüver H., Sagarzazu I. Setting the Agenda or Responding to Voters? Political Parties, Voters and issue attention // West European Politics. 2016. – No39(2). – P. 380-398. 10.1080/01402382.2015.1101295 Карыпов Б.К. Информатизация и цифровизация правотворческой деятельности в Киргизской Республике // Бюллетень науки и практики. 2020. – No8. – С. 210-215. [Karypov B.K. Informatization and digitalization of law-making activities in the Kyrgyz Republic // Bulletin of science and practice. 2020. – No. 8. – P. 210-215.] 10.33619/2414-2948/57/21 Арнаутова А.А. Цифровизация правотворческой деятельности // «Век качества», 2019. – No 2. – С. 32-42. [Arnautova A.A. Digitization of law-making activity // “Vek quality”, 2019. – No. 2. – P. 32-42.] Скурко Е.В. Информационно-правовое обеспечение законодательной деятельности в Российской Федерации // Диссертация к.ю.н.: 12.00.01. – М.: РГБ, 2003. – 131 с. [Skurko E.V. Information and Legal Support of Legislative Activities in the Russian Federation // Dissertation Ph.D. in Law: 12.00.01. – M.: RGB, 2003. – 131 p.]